Being a bit of a nerd I have been part of a pub quiz team (the same one no less) for 32 years! The pubs whose quizzes we have participated in invariably have a music round. One round theme that has reoccurred over the years runs along the lines of big songs that missed the No. 1 chart position, unjustly or not. The classic example is the dreadful 'Shaddap You Face', a novelty hit by the Australian/American Joe Dolce that kept the Ultravox anthem 'Vienna' off the coveted number one slot. Such was the overblown pomposity of the song that half of the UK's record buying public sniggered at such a turn of events and continue to do so more than forty years later!
The example relevant to these humble pages is that a race to No.1 between The Stranglers and The Jam (two of the biggest survivors of the first wave of punk) played out in early 1982 and this too has been a quiz question on several occasions. The problem for The Stranglers was that despite having achieved significant radio play for the first time in years with the quirky, out of character waltz of 'Golden Brown' the competition in February 1982 was stiff, specifically in the form of Weller's mob who released 'A Town Called Malice/Precious as a double A-side. Arguably The Jam were the biggest band in the UK at this time and 'Malice' saw The Jam at the top of their game, both in terms of Weller's lyricism as well as the musical punch they were then delivering. And so it was that the Official UK chart saw 'A Town Called Malice' streak up the chart (the single is seen here in the Melody Maker Chart as a new entry, straight in at number eight (as of 6th February)), rapidly reaching number one, thereby denying The Stranglers the greatest measure of chart success.
However, look closely at the singles chart below, the number one is no less than 'Golden Brown'! The music paper Melody Maker was always rather apart from its UK music weekly rivals, long being a champion of 'real musicianship' which roughly translated to folk and jazz. In this spirit of stubborn independence they continued to produce their own UK single and album chart that was not infrequently at odds with the Official UK Chart returns. So in a nutshell, 'Golden Brown' did reach No. 1.... you just have to look in the right places.
So, next time that particular question surfaces in a pub quiz, maybe I should point out the factual error.... but then again I might just get docked points for being an annoying smart arse!
As an aside, the Official UK Chart has also published a Top 40 of favourite No. 2s (record wise!). Take a look at the esteemed company that 'Golden Brown' is keeping. Sandwiched between James's 'Sit Down' (a song I loath!) and 'Waterloo Sunset' (one of the greatest British pop songs of all time). Seeing the Ray Davies composition there, a parallel comes to mind.... 'A Town Called Malice' is surely a 'Dead End Street' for the 1980's.















